Shelsky's Smoked Fish Tagged: Carroll Gardens, Seafood, Smoked Fish, Bagels

A city of immigrants, New York has many cuisines to which it can lay claim: New York pizza, dirty water hot dogs, Bacon, Egg and Cheese on a Roll, fatty pastrami sandwiches the size of city buses, and David Chang come to mind. But perhaps no cuisine is more associated with New York City, than appetizing. Nothing is more New York, than a bagel with lox and a schmear. Appetizing was brought to New York City by Eastern European Jewish immigrants in the early 20th century. Unfortunately, the number of appetizing shops in New York has dwindled, and in Brooklyn, all but disappeared. Over the past decade, Brooklyn has undergone a renaissance of sorts. Some of New York’s most exciting food is in Brooklyn, and while always an amazingly special place, Brooklyn has become that place whose inhabitants, natives and transplants alike simply never want to leave! From great restaurants to excellent cheese shops and other specialty food shops, Brooklyn is a foodie paradise. What has been missing though, is the Smoked Fish and Appetizing shop of old. Speaking to people around the brownstone Brooklyn, it became clear that like us, they were hankering for appetizing, but sick of having to schlep to Manhattan to get it. So, we are so excited to bring Shelsky’s Smoked Fish to Carroll Gardens. Shelsky’s is a New-Brooklyn, updated nod to the traditional smoked fish and appetizing shops that dotted the Lower East Side and Brooklyn decades ago. We are thrilled to be here, and look forward to seeing you in our shop.
 

Chalkboard

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish May 10

    For those of you from across the pond, we have Smoked Haddock!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish May 08

    Mother’s Day Brunch http://conta.cc/IVZPtX

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Apr 25

    Introducing the newest sandwich to our lineup – The Holy Mackerel! Peppered Smoked Mackerel, Ben’s Veggie Cream Cheese, and Shelsky’s Cucumer Salad on a Toasted Bialy!
    and…
    We are proud to announce that Mill Basin Bagel Cafe is our new bagel and bialy supplier! Come check out these truly remarkable bagels

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Feb 21

    Chubs, have all but disappeared from the Great Lakes thanks to invasive species of mussels. So, unfortunately we cannot get chubs at the moment. In their absence we found something just as awesome and juicy! Fished by Inuits, we bring you the Omega-3 rich, Bering Cisco!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Feb 17

    We’ve got some new SERIOUSLY AWESOME CHOCOLATE! Pure Dark! Come check it out! Also, new on our shelves – Manischewitz Mandlen and a favorite of my Uncle Michael… Polar Half and Half Grapefruit Soda!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Feb 17

    We’ve got some new SERIOUSLY AWESOME CHOCOLATE! Pure Dark! Come check it out! Also, new on our shelves – Manischewitz Mandlen and a favorite of my Uncle Michael… Polar Half and Half Grapefruit Soda!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Jan 24

    Aside from being in NY, what do Giants fans have that Patriots fans don’t? The opportunity to enjoy a smoked fish platter from Shelsky’s Smoked Fish on Superbowl Sunday! Place your orders now!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Jan 24

    Aside from being in NY, what do Giants fans have that Patriots fans don’t? The opportunity to enjoy a smoked fish platter from Shelsky’s Smoked Fish on Superbowl Sunday! Place your orders now!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 31

    Happy New Year to One and All! Stop in for some smoked awesomeness to round out your New Year’s Eve! Stop in tomorrow for some super salty belly lox on a bialy to help with that hangover!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 30

    Updated Hours for the coming days! Saturday – 8AM to 5PM. Sunday (New Year’s Day) – 10AM-5PM

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 28

    Reminder to get your caviar orders in by tomorrow at 2PM! http://www.shelskys.com/new-years-eve.html

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 22

    Need a last minute Gift Idea? Shelsky’s Gift Certificates are now available online http://www.shelskys.com/gift-certificates.html

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 21

    Special orders for following day pick-up must be placed by 2PM please. We are no longer accepting holiday orders for same day pick-up

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 16

    Please stop by next week to help us light the hanukah candles! We will be lighting them all 8 nights, starting on Tuesday at 5PM.

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 15

    Thai Red Curry Pickled Herring with or without Cashews!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 14

    Come on in to order your holiday herring! NY Times: A Starring Role for the Little Humble Herring http://nyti.ms/rBI00V

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 13

    Consider Shelsky’s Chanukah Central! Dreidles, Latkes, and Gelt, OH MY!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 09

    Hot Smoked Whitefish Chowder!!!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 04

    Honey Cake is in the HOUSE!!!!!!

  • Avatar
    Shelsky's Smoked Fish Dec 03

    It’s a beautifully crisp Saturday! Stop in for some wonderfully moist whitefish, some Treif Salad, or our new Spicy Blue Sandwich!

  • Load More